In recent decades, urban space has been progressively reshaped according to neoliberal logics expressed in commodification, privatization and enclosure, which have profoundly altered its role as a site of public and collective life (Giroux, 2004; Lazzarini, 2020a, 2020b; Mayo, 2024). These transformations tend to produce increasingly segregated and depoliticized environments, restricting access and reproducing monologic narratives of spatial experience (Toolis, 2017). In this sense, the erosion of public space – and public sphere – does not only concern its material dimension, but also the conditions under which democratic encounters, civic participation and dialogic and relational learning can take place (Biesta, 2012). At the same time, urban social life exceeds the logics of planning and control. Within the interstices of the contemporary city, everyday practices – often situated, informal, “obstinate” (Finnegan & Fleming, 2023) – reveal alternative ways of inhabiting and re-signifying space, embedded in grassroots processes of social mobilization and collective action (Choudry, 2009; Melero & Gil-Jaurena, 2009; Gray & Manning, 2022). These practices bring attention to the forms of learning that emerge through living, making and re-making spaces: processes rooted in negotiation, collaboration, and also in contestation and generative conflict. In this perspective, they can illuminate and disrupt consolidated and hegemonic ways of thinking and organizing urban life, opening space for the emergence of new imaginaries (Castoriadis, 1975). Within this landscape, placemaking has emerged as a key – yet deeply contested – concept in attempts to make sense of the relationship between people and space/place. Used primarily in urban studies and in the field of planning practice, the term does not refer to a single, clearly bounded definition, but rather to a constellation of approaches through which spaces are physically and symbolically transformed (P. J. Ellery et al., 2021). While often mobilized within institutional and market-driven contexts, placemaking also encompasses bottom up and everyday practices through which people inhabit space, changing its former configuration and uses (J. Ellery et al., 2017; Akbar & Edelenbos, 2021). Critical approaches to placemaking suggest that it should be understood not merely as design-oriented, but as a political commoning practice (Toolis, 2017; Zitcer, 2020), through which urban space is reclaimed, negotiated and sustained as a shared resource (Harvey, 2012). This perspective becomes particularly relevant when considering more structured and semi-institutionalized spaces, where local associations and collectives engage in the management with one other and with public and/or private institutions. Here, placemaking unfolds through the ongoing negotiation of rules, roles and meanings (Bobadilla et al., 2024). My empirical study aims to explore how these spaces come to be enacted as commons, and the forms of learning that emerge through these processes. It is based on an ethnographic case study in Lecco, Italy, where a former freight station is undergoing regeneration and is envisioned as a future community space. Data collection combines multiple qualitative methods – observations, informal conversations with residents, walking interviews, and focus groups - involving local residents, members of associations and collectives, and institutional actors engaged in the project. Preliminary findings suggest a set of underlying tensions: between openness and real accessibility; between civic imaginaries of public space and forms of private management; and between participatory rhetoric and its concrete enactment, often producing feelings of limited agency and disengagement. These dynamics extend beyond the site itself, prompting further exploration of other collective spaces in the city and informing a broader understanding of how commons are enacted in practice.
Polidori, A. (2026). Placemaking as a Commoning Practice: an Ethnographic Case Study of an Emerging Community Space in Lecco, Italy. In LEARNING AND PRACTICING ACTIVE DEMOCRATIC CITIZENSHIP IN THE STRUGGLE AGAINST GROWING AUTHORITARIANISM. Book of Abstracts (pp.9-10).
Placemaking as a Commoning Practice: an Ethnographic Case Study of an Emerging Community Space in Lecco, Italy
Polidori, A
Primo
2026
Abstract
In recent decades, urban space has been progressively reshaped according to neoliberal logics expressed in commodification, privatization and enclosure, which have profoundly altered its role as a site of public and collective life (Giroux, 2004; Lazzarini, 2020a, 2020b; Mayo, 2024). These transformations tend to produce increasingly segregated and depoliticized environments, restricting access and reproducing monologic narratives of spatial experience (Toolis, 2017). In this sense, the erosion of public space – and public sphere – does not only concern its material dimension, but also the conditions under which democratic encounters, civic participation and dialogic and relational learning can take place (Biesta, 2012). At the same time, urban social life exceeds the logics of planning and control. Within the interstices of the contemporary city, everyday practices – often situated, informal, “obstinate” (Finnegan & Fleming, 2023) – reveal alternative ways of inhabiting and re-signifying space, embedded in grassroots processes of social mobilization and collective action (Choudry, 2009; Melero & Gil-Jaurena, 2009; Gray & Manning, 2022). These practices bring attention to the forms of learning that emerge through living, making and re-making spaces: processes rooted in negotiation, collaboration, and also in contestation and generative conflict. In this perspective, they can illuminate and disrupt consolidated and hegemonic ways of thinking and organizing urban life, opening space for the emergence of new imaginaries (Castoriadis, 1975). Within this landscape, placemaking has emerged as a key – yet deeply contested – concept in attempts to make sense of the relationship between people and space/place. Used primarily in urban studies and in the field of planning practice, the term does not refer to a single, clearly bounded definition, but rather to a constellation of approaches through which spaces are physically and symbolically transformed (P. J. Ellery et al., 2021). While often mobilized within institutional and market-driven contexts, placemaking also encompasses bottom up and everyday practices through which people inhabit space, changing its former configuration and uses (J. Ellery et al., 2017; Akbar & Edelenbos, 2021). Critical approaches to placemaking suggest that it should be understood not merely as design-oriented, but as a political commoning practice (Toolis, 2017; Zitcer, 2020), through which urban space is reclaimed, negotiated and sustained as a shared resource (Harvey, 2012). This perspective becomes particularly relevant when considering more structured and semi-institutionalized spaces, where local associations and collectives engage in the management with one other and with public and/or private institutions. Here, placemaking unfolds through the ongoing negotiation of rules, roles and meanings (Bobadilla et al., 2024). My empirical study aims to explore how these spaces come to be enacted as commons, and the forms of learning that emerge through these processes. It is based on an ethnographic case study in Lecco, Italy, where a former freight station is undergoing regeneration and is envisioned as a future community space. Data collection combines multiple qualitative methods – observations, informal conversations with residents, walking interviews, and focus groups - involving local residents, members of associations and collectives, and institutional actors engaged in the project. Preliminary findings suggest a set of underlying tensions: between openness and real accessibility; between civic imaginaries of public space and forms of private management; and between participatory rhetoric and its concrete enactment, often producing feelings of limited agency and disengagement. These dynamics extend beyond the site itself, prompting further exploration of other collective spaces in the city and informing a broader understanding of how commons are enacted in practice.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


